November 19, 2024
4 min

Best UX Research Methods for Every Phase of Product Development

What is UX research?

User experience (UX) research, or user research as it’s commonly referred to, is an important part of the product design process. Primarily, UX research involves using different research methods to gather information about how your users interact with your product. It is an essential part of developing, building and launching a product that truly meets the requirements of your users. 

UX research is essential at all stages of a products' life cycle:

  1. Planning
  2. Building
  3. Introduction
  4. Growth & Maturity

While there is no one single time to conduct UX research it is best-practice to continuously gather information throughout the lifetime of your product. The good news is many of the UX research methods do not fit just one phase either, and can (and should) be used repeatedly. After all, there are always new pieces of functionality to test and new insights to discover. We introduce you to best-practice UX research methods for each lifecycle phase of your product.

1. Product planning phase

While the planning phase it is about creating a product that fits your organization, your organization’s needs and meeting a gap in the market it’s also about meeting the needs, desires and requirements of your users. Through UX research you’ll learn which features are necessary to be aligned with your users. And of course, user research lets you test your UX design before you build, saving you time and money.

Qualitative Research Methods

Usability Testing - Observational

One of the best ways to learn about your users and how they interact with your product is to observe them in their own environment. Watch how they accomplish tasks, the order they do things, what frustrates them, and what makes the task easier and/or more enjoyable for your subject. The data can be collated to inform the usability of your product, improving intuitive design, and what resonates with users.

Competitive Analysis

Reviewing products already in the market can be a great start to the planning process. Why are your competitors’ products successful and how well do they behave for users. Learn from their successes, and even better build on where they may not be performing the best and find your niche in the market.

Quantitative Research Methods

Surveys and Questionnaires

Surveys are useful for collecting feedback or understanding attitudes. You can use the learnings from your survey of a subset of users to draw conclusions about a larger population of users.

There are two types of survey questions:

Closed questions are designed to capture quantitative information. Instead of asking users to write out answers, these questions often use multi-choice answers.

Open questions are designed to capture qualitative information such as motivations and context.  Typically, these questions require users to write out an answer in a text field.

2. Product building phase

Once you've completed your product planning research, you’re ready to begin the build phase for your product. User research studies undertaken during the build phase enable you to validate the UX team’s deliverables before investing in the technical development.

Qualitative Research Methods

Focus groups

Generally involve 5-10 participants and include demographically similar individuals. The study is set up so that members of the group can interact with one another and can be carried out in person or remotely.


Besides learning about the participants’ impressions and perceptions of your product, focus group findings also include what users believe to be a product’s most important features, problems they might encounter while using the product, as well as their experiences with other products, both good and bad.

Quantitative Research Methods

Card sorting gives insight into how users think. Tools like card sorting reveal where your users expect to find certain information or complete specific tasks. This is especially useful for products with complex or multiple navigations and contributes to the creation of an intuitive information architecture and user experience.

Tree testing gives insight into where users expect to find things and where they’re getting lost within your product. Tools like tree testing help you test your information architecture.
Card sorting and tree testing are often used together. Depending on the purpose of your research and where you are at with your product, they can provide a fully rounded view of your information architecture.

3. Product introduction phase

You’ve launched your product, wahoo! And you’re ready for your first real life, real time users. Now it’s time to optimize your product experience. To do this, you’ll need to understand how your new users actually use your product.

Qualitative Research Methods

Usability testing involves testing a product with users. Typically it involves observing users as they try to follow and complete a series of tasks. As a result you can evaluate if the design is intuitive and if there are any usability problems.

User Interviews - A user interview is designed to get a deeper understanding of a particular topic. Unlike a usability test, where you’re more likely to be focused on how people use your product, a user interview is a guided conversation aimed at better understanding your users. This means you’ll be capturing details like their background, pain points, goals and motivations.

Quantitative Research Methods

A/B Testing is a way to compare two versions of a design in order to work out which is more effective. It’s typically used to test two versions of the same webpage, for example, using a different headline, image or call to action to see which one converts more effectively. This method offers a way to validate smaller design choices where you might not have the data to make an informed decision, like the color of a button or the layout of a particular image.

Flick-click testing shows you where people click first when trying to complete a task on a website. In most cases, first-click testing is performed on a very simple wireframe of a website, but it can also be carried out on a live website using a tool like first-time clicking.

4. Growth and maturity phase

If you’ve reached the growth stage, fantastic news! You’ve built a great product that’s been embraced by your users. Next on your to-do list is growing your product by increasing your user base and then eventually reaching maturity and making a profit on your hard work.

Growing your product involves building new or advanced features to satisfy specific customer segments. As you plan and build these enhancements, go through the same research and testing process you used to create the first release. The same holds true for enhancements as well as a new product build — user research ensures you’re building the right thing in the best way for your customers.

Qualitative research methods

User interviews will focus on how your product is working or if it’s missing any features, enriching your knowledge about your product and users.

It allows you to test your current features, discover new possibilities for additional features and think about discarding  existing ones. If your customers aren’t using certain features, it might be time to stop supporting them to reduce costs and help you grow your profits during the maturity stage.

Quantitative research methods

Surveys and questionnaires can help gather information around which features will work best for your product, enhancing and improving the user experience. 

A/B testing during growth and maturity occurs within your sales and onboarding processes. Making sure you have a smooth onboarding process increases your conversion rate and reduces wasted spend — improving your bottom line.

Final Thoughts: Why Continuous UX Research Matters

UX research testing throughout the lifecycle of your product helps you continuously evolve and develop a product that responds to what really matters - your users.

Talking to, testing, and knowing your users will allow you to push your product in ways that make sense with the data to back up decisions. Go forth and create the product that meets your organizations needs by delivering the very best user experience for your users.

Share this article
Author
Optimal
Workshop

Related articles

View all blog articles
Learn more
1 min read

5 key areas for effective ResearchOPs

Simply put, ResearchOps is about making sure your research operations are robust, thought through and managed. 

Having systems and processes around your UX research and your team keep everyone (and everything) organized. Making user research projects quicker to get started and more streamlined to run. And robust sharing, socializing, and knowledge storage means that everyone can understand the research insights and findings and put these to use - across the organization. And even better, find these when they need them. 

Using the same tools across the team allows the research team to learn from each other, and previous research projects and be able to compare apples with apples, with everyone included. Bringing the team together across tools, research and results.

We go into more detail in our ebook ResearchOps Checklist about exactly what you can do to make sure your research team is running at its best. Let’s take a quick look at 5 way to ensure you have the grounding for a successful ResearchOps team.

1. Knowledge management 📚

What do you do with all of the insights and findings of a user research project? How do you store them, how do you manage the insights, and how do you share and socialize?

Having processes in place that manage this knowledge is important to the longevity of your research. From filing to sharing across platforms, it all needs to be standardized so everyone can search, find and share.

2. Guidelines and process templates 📝

Providing a framework for how to run research projects is are important. Building on the knowledge base from previous research can improve research efficiencies and cut down on groundwork and administration. Making research projects quicker and more streamlined to get underway.

3. Governance 🏛

User research is all about people, real people. It is incredibly important that any research be legal, safe, and ethical. Having effective governance covered is vital.

4. Tool stack 🛠

Every research team needs a ‘toolbox’ that they can use whenever they need to run card sorts, tree tests, usability tests, user interviews, and more. But which software and tools to use?

Making sure that the team is using the same tools also helps with future research projects, learning from previous projects, and ensuring that the information is owned and run by the organization (rather than whichever individuals prefer). Reduce logins and password shares, and improve security with organization-wide tools and platforms. 

5. Recruitment 👱🏻👩👩🏻👧🏽👧🏾

Key to great UX research is the ability to recruit quality participants - fast! Having strong processes in place for screening, scheduling, sampling, incentivizing, and managing participants needs to be top of the list when organizing the team.

Wrap Up 💥

Each of these ResearchOps processes are not independent of the other. And neither do they flow from one to the other. They are part of a total wrap around for the research team, creating processes, systems and tools that are built to serve the team. Allowing them to focus on the job of doing great research and generating insights and findings that develop the very best user experience. 

Afterall, we are creating user experiences that keep our users engaged and coming back. Why not look at the teams user experience and make the most of that. Freeing time and space to socialize and share the findings with the organization. 

Learn more
1 min read

Democratizing UX research: empowering cross-functional teams

In today's fast-paced product development landscape, the ability to quickly gather and act on user insights is more critical than ever. While dedicated UX researchers play a crucial role, there's a growing trend towards democratizing UX research – empowering team members across various functions to contribute to and benefit from user insights. Let's explore how this approach can transform your organization's approach to user-centered design.

Benefits of a democratized UXR approach

Democratizing UX research is a transformative approach that empowers organizations to unlock the full potential of user insights. By breaking down traditional barriers and involving a broader range of team members in the research process, companies can foster a culture of user-centricity, accelerate decision-making, and drive innovation. This inclusive strategy not only enhances the depth and breadth of user understanding but also aligns diverse perspectives to create more impactful, user-friendly products and services. Here are a few of the benefits of this movement:

Increased research velocity

By enabling more team members to conduct basic research, organizations can gather insights more frequently and rapidly. This means that instead of waiting for dedicated UX researchers to be available, product managers, designers, or marketers can quickly run simple surveys or usability tests. For example, a product manager could use a user-friendly tool to get quick feedback on a new feature idea, allowing the team to iterate faster. This increased velocity helps organizations stay agile and responsive to user needs in a fast-paced market.

Broader perspective

Cross-functional participation brings diverse viewpoints to research, potentially uncovering insights that might be missed by specialized researchers alone. A developer might ask questions from a technical feasibility standpoint, while a marketer might focus on brand perception. This diversity in approach can lead to richer, more comprehensive insights. For instance, during a user interview, a sales team member might pick up on specific pain points related to competitor products that a UX researcher might not have thought to explore.

Enhanced user-centricity

When more team members engage directly with users, it fosters a culture of user-centricity across the organization. This direct exposure to user feedback and behaviors helps all team members develop empathy for the user. As a result, user needs and preferences become a central consideration in all decision-making processes, not just in UX design. For example, seeing users struggle with a feature firsthand might motivate a developer to champion user-friendly improvements in future sprints.

Improved research adoption

Team members who participate in research are more likely to understand and act on the insights generated. When people are involved in gathering data, they have a deeper understanding of the context and nuances of the findings. This personal investment leads to greater buy-in and increases the likelihood that research insights will be applied in practical ways. For instance, a product manager who conducts user interviews is more likely to prioritize features based on actual user needs rather than assumptions.

Resource optimization

Democratization allows dedicated researchers to focus on more complex, high-value research initiatives. By offloading simpler research tasks to other team members, professional UX researchers can dedicate their expertise to more challenging projects, such as longitudinal studies, complex usability evaluations, or strategic research initiatives. This optimization ensures that specialized skills are applied where they can have the most significant impact.

Our survey revealed that organizations with a more democratized approach to UXR tend to have higher levels of research maturity and integration into product development processes. This correlation suggests that democratization not only increases the quantity of research conducted but also enhances its quality and impact. Organizations that empower cross-functional teams to participate in UXR often develop more sophisticated research practices over time.

For example, these organizations might:

  • Have better-defined research processes and guidelines
  • Integrate user insights more consistently into decision-making at all levels
  • Develop more advanced metrics for measuring the impact of UXR
  • Foster a culture where challenging assumptions with user data is the norm
  • Create more opportunities for collaboration between different departments around user insights

By democratizing UXR, organizations can create a virtuous cycle where increased participation leads to better research practices, which in turn drives more value from UXR activities. This approach helps to embed user-centricity deeply into the organizational culture, leading to better products and services that truly meet user needs.

Strategies for upskilling people who do research (PWDRs)

To successfully democratize UXR, it's crucial to provide proper training and support:

1. UXR basics workshops

Offer regular training sessions on fundamental research methods and best practices. These workshops should cover a range of topics, including:

  • Introduction to user research methodologies (e.g., interviews, surveys, usability testing)
  • Basics of research design and planning
  • Participant recruitment strategies
  • Data analysis techniques
  • Ethical considerations in user research

For example, a monthly "UXR 101" workshop could be organized, where different aspects of UX research are covered in depth. These sessions could be led by experienced researchers and include practical exercises to reinforce learning.

Check out our 101 Guides

2. Mentorship programs

Pair non-researchers with experienced UX researchers for guidance and support. This one-on-one relationship allows for personalized learning and hands-on guidance. 

Mentors can:

  • Provide feedback on research plans
  • Offer advice on challenging research scenarios
  • Share best practices and personal experiences
  • Help mentees navigate the complexities of user research in their specific organizational context

A formal mentorship program could be established with clear goals, regular check-ins, and a defined duration (e.g., 6 months), after which mentees could become mentors themselves, scaling the program.

3. Research playbooks

Develop standardized templates and guidelines for common research activities. These playbooks serve as go-to resources for non-researchers, ensuring consistency and quality across studies. 

They might include:

  • Step-by-step guides for different research methods
  • Templates for research plans, screeners, and report structures
  • Best practices for participant interaction
  • Guidelines for data privacy and ethical considerations
  • Tips for presenting and socializing research findings

For instance, a "Usability Testing Playbook" could walk a product manager through the entire process of planning, conducting, and reporting on a usability test.

Check out Optimal Playbooks

4. Collaborative research

Involve non-researchers in studies led by experienced UX professionals to provide hands-on learning opportunities.

This approach allows non-researchers to:

  • Observe best practices in action
  • Contribute to real research projects
  • Understand the nuances and challenges of UX research
  • Build confidence in their research skills under expert guidance

For example, a designer could assist in a series of user interviews, gradually taking on more responsibility with each session under the researcher's supervision.

5. Continuous learning resources

Provide access to online courses, webinars, and industry events to foster ongoing skill development. This could include:

  • Subscriptions to UX research platforms and tools
  • Access to online course libraries (e.g., Coursera, LinkedIn Learning)
  • Budget for attending UX conferences and workshops
  • Internal knowledge sharing sessions where team members present on recent learnings or projects

An internal UX research resource hub could be created, curating relevant articles, videos, and courses for easy access by team members.

As one UX leader in our study noted, "It's been exciting to see [UXR] evolve as a discipline and see where it is today, and to see the various backgrounds and research specialisms that [user] researchers have today is not something I'd have expected."

This quote highlights the dynamic nature of UX research and the diversity it now encompasses. The field has evolved to welcome practitioners from various backgrounds, each bringing unique perspectives and skills. This diversity enriches the discipline and makes it more adaptable to different organizational contexts.

For example:

  • A former teacher might excel at educational research for EdTech products
  • A psychologist could bring deep insights into user behavior and motivation
  • A data scientist might introduce advanced analytical techniques to UX research

By embracing this diversity and providing comprehensive support for skill development, organizations can create a rich ecosystem of UX research capabilities. This not only democratizes the practice but also elevates its overall quality and impact.

The key to successful democratization lies in balancing accessibility with rigor. While making UX research more widely practiced, it's crucial to maintain high standards and ethical practices. The strategies outlined above help achieve this balance by providing structure, guidance, and ongoing support to those new to UX research, while leveraging the expertise of experienced researchers to ensure quality and depth in the organization's overall research efforts.

Tools and platforms enabling broader participation

The democratization of UXR has been greatly facilitated by comprehensive, user-friendly research platforms like Optimal Workshop. Our all-in-one solution offers a suite of tools designed to empower both seasoned researchers and non-researchers alike:

Surveys

Our intuitive survey creation tool allows anyone in your organization to quickly design and distribute surveys. With customizable templates and an easy-to-use interface, gathering user feedback has never been simpler.

Tree Testing and Card Sorting

These powerful tools simplify the process of conducting information architecture and card sorting studies. Non-researchers can easily set up and run tests to validate navigation structures and content organization.

Qualitative Insights

Our powerful qualitative analysis tool enables team members across your organization to efficiently analyze and synthesize user interview data. With its user-friendly interface, our Qualitative Insights tool makes deriving meaningful insights from qualitative research accessible to researchers and non-researchers alike.

First-click Testing

This easy-to-use first-click testing tool empowers anyone in your team to quickly set up and run tests to evaluate the effectiveness of their designs. First-click Testing simplifies the process of gathering initial user impressions, allowing for rapid iteration and improvement of user interfaces.

These tools, integrated into a single, user-friendly platform, make it possible for non-researchers to conduct basic studies and contribute to the overall research effort without extensive training. The intuitive design of the Optimal Workshop UXR and insights platform ensures that team members across different functions can easily engage in user research activities, from planning and execution to analysis and sharing of insights.

By providing a comprehensive, accessible platform, Optimal Workshop plays a crucial role in democratizing UX research, enabling organizations to build a more user-centric culture and make data-driven decisions at all levels.

Balancing democratization with expertise

While democratizing UXR offers numerous benefits, it's crucial to strike a balance with professional expertise. This balance involves establishing quality control measures, reserving complex research initiatives for trained professionals, maintaining strategic oversight by experienced researchers, providing clear guidelines on research ethics and data privacy, and leveraging dedicated researchers' expertise for insight synthesis. 

Our survey revealed that organizations successfully balancing democratization with expertise tend to see the highest impact from their UXR efforts. The goal of democratization is not to replace dedicated researchers but to expand the organization's capacity for generating user insights. By empowering cross-functional teams to participate in UXR, companies can foster a more user-centric culture, increase the velocity of insight generation, and ultimately create products that better meet user needs. 

As we look to the future, the trend towards democratization is likely to continue, and organizations that can effectively balance broad participation with professional expertise will be best positioned to thrive in an increasingly user-centric business landscape.

Ready to democratize your UX research? Optimal Workshop's platform empowers your entire team to contribute to user insights while maintaining professional quality. Our intuitive tools accelerate research velocity and foster a user-centric culture. 

Start your free trial today and transform your UXR practice. 

Learn more
1 min read

What’s the difference between UI and UX?

UI and UX are two terms that are often used interchangeably and confused for one another, but what do they actually mean? And is there a crossover between them?

These two terms have only grown in use in recent years, thanks largely to the exploding technology sector. This is great news. For organizations, effectively harnessing UX and UI enables them to build products and services that people will actually want to use – and continue using. For users, they’ll have access to products designed for them. 

What is UX? 🤳🎯

User experience (UX as it’s commonly called) refers to the experience that a person has with a product or service. 

We can determine whether a user experience is good or bad based on how easy (or difficult) it is for users to interact with the various elements of a product or service. Is the sign-up flow easy to use? Does the CTA button on the homepage encourage users to click? UX design exists to answer questions like these – and here’s how.

At the core of UX design is user research, which you can use to understand customer pain points and actually build products designed for the people using them. Typically, user research involves the use of a number of different research methods designed to answer specific questions. Card sorting, for example, can show you how people think the information on your website should be arranged.

Designer and information architect Peter Morville came up with the user experience honeycomb, which demonstrates the various components of UX design.

The UX honeycomb. Source.

Don Norman of Nielsen Norman Group defines UX as “[encompassing] all aspects of the end-users interaction with the company, its services, and its products”.

If this seems broad, that’s because it is. UX actually extends beyond just the digital products of an organization and can be used for areas like retail, customer service and more. In fact, there’s actually a growing movement to replace UX with customer experience (CX), as a way of encompassing all of these disparate elements.

What is UI? 🪄📲

User interface (UI), in the most stripped-back definition, is the interface by which a user and a computer system communicate with one another. This includes the touchscreen on your smartphone, the screen on your laptop, your mouse and keyboard and countless other mechanisms.

With this in mind, user interface design is focused on the elements that users will see on these interfaces, such as buttons, text and images. UI design is all about layout, look and feel. The objective of UI design is to visually guide users through an interface so they can complete their task. In a nutshell, you don’t want a user to think too hard about what they’re doing.

Shown here: The user interface of the Tesla Model S. Source.

UI has its origins in the 1980s, when Xerox developed the very first graphical user interface (GUI). Instead of needing to interact with a computer through a programming language, people could now use icons, menus and buttons. The rest, as they say, is history. Apple came along with the Macintosh computer in 1984 (bringing with it the first point and click mouse), and now we’re all carrying smartphones with touch screens that even a baby can operate.

Like UX, UI has grown significantly – going far beyond what you’ll see on a computer screen. Those involved in the field of UI design today will work as much on the interfaces of computer programs and apps as they will on the user interfaces of cars, wearable devices and technologies in the home. If current trends continue, UI design is likely to become an even bigger field in the years ahead.

What’s the difference between UX and UI? 👀

UX and UI are both essential components of a product or service. You can’t have one without the other, and, as we’ve explored, neglecting one could have serious consequences for your product’s success.

The difference between UX and UI is that UX is focused on the experience of using something and UI is focused on the look and feel of the interface. 

“User Experience (UX) and User Interface (UI) are some of the most confused and misused terms in our field. A UI without UX is like a painter slapping paint onto a canvas without thought; while UX without UI is like the frame of a sculpture with no paper mache on it. A great product experience starts with UX followed by UI. Both are essential for the product’s success”. - Rahul Varshney, co-creator of Foster.fm

The difference between UX and UI is that UX is focused on the experience of using something and UI is focused on the look and feel of the interface. 

Or, if you’d prefer a statement from venerable Nielsen Norman Group: “It’s important to distinguish the total user experience from the UI, even though the UI is obviously an extremely important part of the design. As an example, consider a website with movie reviews. Even if the UI for finding a film is perfect, the UX will be poor for a user who wants information about a small independent release if the underlying database only contains movies from the major studios”.

With this in mind, let’s now take a look at the people behind UX and UI. What do the roles look like in these fields? And, more importantly, what do they involve?

UX and UI jobs guide 📱🧑🏻💻

  • Visual designer: This role works with other design roles in the organization (brand, marketing, etc) to ensure designs match brand guidelines. Visual designers also work with UX designers to verify that designs meet accessibility and usability requirements.
  • UX strategist: At the core, a UX strategist should act as a champion of good UX. That is to say, work to ensure the principles of usability and human-centered design are well understood and utilized. They should also assume some of the responsibility of product-market fit, and work with product managers and the ‘business’ side of the organization to mesh business requirements with user requirements.
  • UX designer: The most common UX profession, UX designers should have a strong understanding of the principles of UX design as well as some research ability. Essentially a jack of all trades, the UX designer will float between all stages of the UX lifecycle, helping out with usability tests, putting together prototypes and working with other areas of the organization.
  • Service designer: The service designer looks at the entire end-to-end process and works with other designers, pulling them when required to liaise on visual designs and UI work. In a smaller organization, the responsibilities of this role will typically be absorbed by other roles, but eventually, there comes a time for the service designer. 

Wrap up 🎬

UX and UI as terms are only going to continue to grow, especially as technology and technology companies continue to proliferate across the globe. If you want to make sure that the user experience and user interfaces of your product or service are fit for the people using them, there’s no better place to start than with user research using powerful tools.

Seeing is believing

Explore our tools and see how Optimal makes gathering insights simple, powerful, and impactful.